Artificial Intelligence and Christian Ethics - Salisbury Cathedral

Artificial Intelligence and Christian Ethics

Matthew 22.34-36

 

The celebrations this summer of 250 years since American independence inadvertently overshadowed another anniversary from the same year, the impact of which is arguably no less significant on the course of world history. March 1776 saw the publication of the opus magnum of Scottish philosopher Adam Smith. Smith’s book An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations laid the foundations of modern economics and presaged the intellectual superstructures of the industrial revolution and free market trade.

Smith’s great breakthrough in The Wealth of Nations was to reject the prevailing orthodoxy which said that the acquisition of affluence required zero-sum competition between imperial states – the notion that I can only improve my position by seizing it from you. Against this, Smith argued that productivity could be increased through competition, deregulation, and innovation like the division of labour. Through these processes Smith thought that self-interested individuals would unwittingly advance social benefit by stimulating economic growth. He concluded that the heavy hand of the state is as nothing when compared to the invisible yet irresistible forces of supply and demand.

We stand on the threshold of the next economic revolution, one which will be catalysed by Artificial Intelligence. A condition of a truly free-market is transparent information, perfect knowledge about the quality and price of goods and services. The internet has revolutionised such knowledge over the last three decades and AI is now taking this to the next level.

Through Artificial Intelligence the internet has become self-reflexive, able not only to review and regurgitate information, but actively to learn from data that has been uploaded to it. If you want an accessible explanation of how such ‘large language models’ work, I commend the talk given by Tim Bull in this Cathedral recently, the video of which can be found in the 2026 Lent Lectures playlist on our YouTube channel.

We can only begin to glimpse the potential of AI for scientific research and business efficiency – just as Adam Smith and George Washington could not have fully foreseen the outcomes of the forces which they unleashed 250 years ago. Nonetheless we are acutely aware of many risks associated with AI:

  • Changes to employment structures are already in train, with jobs in many sectors being replaced by electronic research tools.
  • Meanwhile, an eruption of AI-generated correspondence is threatening to suffocate governments and businesses.
    Environmentalists are reprimanding the resource-hungry data centres needed to drive AI, especially in parts of America where water is in short supply and where federal policy is hampering the roll-out of lost-cost low-carbon electricity.
  • Individuals are at risk of pursuing emotional fulfilment with chatbots instead of seeking healthy relationships in the real world with other people and (for that matter) with God. Such rabbit holes will gape widest at times of vulnerability and loss. For instance, I recently read about the arrival of ‘grief bots’ which take the digital footprint of someone who has died in order to simulate their character.

The list of challenges continues…

  • Competition for finance among the leading AI companies is inflating an economic bubble which might burst at any moment.
  • And competition for technical advantage is stoking tensions between China and America so as to disincentivise regulation of AI. As with nuclear weapons in the second half of the twentieth century, unilateral disarmament of artificial intelligence is not going to happen.
  • And here, I suggest, we reach our greatest worries about AI, with the fear that in the imminent future we might lose control, either because AIs mimic consciousness so as to gain legal rights, or – in the worst-case scenario – because AIs develop an unhealthy desire for self-preservation and turn Frankenstein’s Monster against their human creators.

What might our faith tradition say to this brave new world? Can the dusty pages of Scripture offer anything of relevance to a society which rests on such shaky pillars?

On first consideration we might conclude that Christianity has little to bring to the table. After all, the Bible was written centuries before the invention of electricity and the manifold advances of modern science. This means that the most famous guidelines we get in the Bible, the ten commandments, advise about matters such as profaning the Lord’s name, and coveting our neighbour’s ass, but say precious little about digital security nor the futures electricity market.

Seemingly, Jesus does no better in today’s gospel. When the lawyer asks his incarnate intelligence to filter the half million words of Hebrew Scripture into a pithy summary, he comes up with that line about loving ‘the Lord your God with all your heart, and soul, and mind… and your neighbour as yourself’. Just what does that mean – and what use is it in the face of a digital arms race?

But, look, the Bible has never been an ethical handbook, a Haynes manual to the world with step-by-step guidance on what to do in any given circumstance. It has no blueprint for the boards of Anthropic and Palantir, just as it did not advise William the Conqueror when to cross the channel, nor tell Elias of Derham where to plant this Cathedral.

The Bible has never been an infallible map for every moral dilemma and daily decision. God has not created us as robots. To be made in his image is to include an element of moral freedom – and with this comes a related element of moral hazard.

Indeed, it is precisely because of this openness and freedom that the Bible is relevant in every age – including our own. Holy writ is a moral framework distilled over a thousand years, not an encyclopaedia with pat answers. We have to keep reading it, and keep working at our choices, together and as a community. The risk – indeed the certainty – is that we won’t always get it right. But the challenge to pick ourselves up and try again tomorrow remains a constant.

It is not without significance that artificial intelligence is the theme of the first encyclical of Pope Leo, published back in the spring. Entitled Magnifica Humanitas, magnificent humanity, this encyclical reaffirms the dignity of the individual. Leo insists that human experience and intelligence have value because they are made by God. They cannot be reduced to mere data.

Magnifica Humanitas goes on to contrast the technocratic striving which failed to build the tower of Babel with the collaborative mutuality that reconstructed Jerusalem during the time of Nehemiah. From this, Pope Leo proceeds to affirm established Roman Catholic social teaching as a basis for regulating AI in the service of the common good.

This encyclical is a document of universal significance, which leaders of industry and nations should digest, a basis on which they could collaborate. Unilateral disarmament of AI is unrealistic, but praying and working towards multi-lateral regulation is surely prudent.

Other ideas from our tradition offer further conceptual perspective on AI. Centuries before anyone in Silicon Valley dreamt up artificial intelligence, medieval theologians insisted that only God has perfect knowledge. Only God – not computers. The scholastics said that, logically prior to his decision to create God has intelligence of all possibilities, and that logically posterior to the decision to create God has knowledge of all actualities, including events which we cannot predict because to us they are in the future.

Motions and thoughts before they grow

Thy Knowledge doth Espy.
What unborn Ages are to do

Is done before thine Eye.[1]

That is not a verse written by Google Gemini but words of seventeenth-century Anglican priest John Mason, part of a larger poem about divine knowledge, some of which we sing as the hymn ‘How shall I sing that Majesty?’

Artificial intelligence is taking economic principles documented by Adam Smith 250 years ago to new levels, and posing all sorts of practical and moral challenges in the process. As a technology it is utterly novel. However, we can also see how it fits into slower tectonic patterns of history. Given this, the framework of wisdom distilled by our Jewish forebears and re-spun by Jesus into the Golden Rule of love for God and neighbour is as applicable today as it ever was. And applicability is the key thing because while only God has perfect knowledge of what we will chose to do when presented by a given set of circumstances, the awesome responsibility of making each choice continues to rest on our shoulders.

 

 

[1] Mason, John, Songs of Praise to Almighty God, 4.